Julia or Charlize, who is better at being the Evil Queen?

Well, the problem with this story is that there is not much to it. It's only a fairy tale with few things happening so whenever a film based on Snow White is produced a lot of creativity has to be put in order to fill the standard one hour and forty five minutes most movies last. This also means that every interpretation will imply a lot of liberties in order to deliver a story that Holliwood producers may  find potentially profitable. 

The version with Julia Roberts is a family movie. There is humor, no unnecessary epic battles, no real violence; there is a Snow White that actually looks innocent, and no loose ends. The story moves at a good pace and the acting of most of the cast is acceptable with Julia Roberts being the natural star. Without her it would be just another movie. It's just a matter of seing her acting. She is the one that makes that movie interesting and her actions keep the film going. In fact at the beginning the witch queen announces the movie is about her and not Snow White. So true: the parts that do not include her are the boring parts.
The other version, the one with Charlize Teron, is that of a very cruel person who has become so because circumstances forced her to embrace evil and is in many ways a victim of herself. This film, Snow White and The Huntsman, is darker in essence and much more epic with a Snow White that does not hesitate to don an armor and lead an army to reclaim her castle. There are also lots of facts left unexplained such as that of the kingdom the queen belonged to before, and the real connection between her brother and her which has, at times, incestuous connotations. The queen is depicted as a mixture of a powerful enchantress and some sort of vampire that feeds on the juvenile energy of her victims. She also hates all men and wants (how original!) to conquer the world. The mirror is also a distinct element in each story. in Mirror, mirror the image in the queen's mirror is that of herself but acts and speaks as though it were a separate individual and in order to talk to it the queen first has to go through a portal that takes her to another part of the world or another reality (that is never explained). In  Snow White and The Huntsman, the mirror  is an extension of a wong dish that appears in human form and that only the queen can see.There is also the figure of the Huntsman. What is his purpose? Why is it there? In the end, the story could have been told without him. 
I would say that both films are not excellent but only acceptable with essential differences. More than a family film Snow White and The Huntsman is an epic story without the typical ending of the boy marrying the girl replaced by the scene of Snow White's ascension to the throne. I like Charlize Theron's presence and her acting really delivers, but in the end Julia is just one step ahead of everyone and everything else.                                                        

Comments

Einsen said…
another fairy tale movie?? seriously? im fed up of re-makes, even if they make a great movie, or change the basis... come on! get original again hollywood!!
July 26, 2012 at 7:33 PM
Luis Bermudes said…
Hard to do, old habits die hard they say.
July 28, 2012 at 8:24 PM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

How do you say MIRADOR in English?

Image
"Hmm, why do I have this nagging feeling that someone is watching me watching?" In Spanish, a MIRADOR is any place that allows a privileged view of the surroundings. In English, a MIRADOR is a VIEWPOINT or a LOOKOUT. Another possible translation is VANTAGE POINT, though in a tourist context this term is a bit less common.
Read more

The Maps of Ship-Trap Island

Image
Once I had my high school students read The Most Dangerous Game, a short story by Richard Connell. Rainsford, the main character, is a professional hunter traveling by ship to his next hunting area, accidentally ends up in an island called Ship- Trap island. When he goes into the island he finds there are two men living in a palace in the island. One of them is a Cossack general and the other, his brutish servant.  The Cossack is called general Zaroff who is also  a game hunter but has become bored of hunting regular game and now uses the island's unique position to capture sailors from shipwrecks. He lets them go first and next after some time he hunts them down. Rainford's arrival who is worldwide famous presents Zaroff with a rare opportunity to find excitement in hunting again by hunting another hunter. Little does Zaroff know that Rainsford is The Most Dangerous Game in the World and hunting him will not be easy at all. My students enjoyed themselves at reading...
Read more

How do you say EXAMEN SUPLETORIO in English?

Image
Darn! I wonder if there's a Make Up exam for this Make up exam! I remember that long ago I asked my distinguished and knowledgeable colleagues of that time to enlighten me and tell me the right English word for what we know in Ecuador as EXAMEN SUPLETORIO or EXAMEN DE RECUPERACION.  After hearing Recovery exam or Supplemenary test and even Supletory exam, I was not convinced so I decided to go to a higher authority and looked up one of those encyclopedic dictionaries from Oxford or Cambridge university (these were the pre-browser times) and found the right expression is MAKE UP EXAM which is taken when an exam has been missed or when a student needs to change one score with a more favorable one. The British say RECUPERATION EXAM which is perhaps more practical since to some people the term Make Up is confusing. Make-up is the word for the wearing of cosmetics. There are Make-up tests which are oriented to future Make-up artists.
Read more